Christian kerslake is there a single meaning of the term immanence in the philosophy of gilles deleuze. In this paper i discuss with deleuze the relationship between metaphysical and political senses of eualit in spinozas ok. Identifies immanence as the original impetus and the driving force behind deleuzes philosophy in 5 chapters dealing with the status of thought itself, ontology. Dark deleuze criticizes productivism for its reliance on models of reproduction and. Immanence, meaning existing or remaining within generally offers a relative opposition to transcendence, that which is beyond or outside. The theme of this special issue allows for a rereading of the terminology of differentciation, which deleuze. Although the notion of immanence is frequently held to be central to deleuze s philosophy, his use of the term can hardly. Postsecularism and the future of immanence, edinburgh university press, 2014, 220pp. Deleuze s published writings, immanence is repeatedly contrasted with the philosophies of transcendence, and the philosophers deleuze frequently returns to scotus, spinoza, nietzsche, leibniz, and hume each offers, as deleuze understands them, important contributions to the philosophy of immanence. Nietzsche thus defines the task of his philosophy, or more generally, the task of the philosophy of the future. Gilles deleuze, nietzsche and philosophy but, after all, this was the proper task of a history of thought, as against a history of behaviors or representations. It seeks to extract the inner consistency of deleuze s thought by returning to its source or to what, following deleuze s own vocabulary, it calls the eventof that thought. Deleuze s philosophy of immanence is held to be fundamentally characterised by its opposition to all philosophies of transcendence. Itis to the degree that he goes beyond the aporias ofthe subject and the object that johann fichte, in his last philosophy.
Underneath the represented world of subjects and properties is a differential field of intensity. The following text opened the conference, the concept of immanence in philosophy and the arts, held in vienna in may 2016. Ultimately, he argues, immanence is an infinite task, and transcendence the opposition with which philosophy. Deleuze also wrote a series of influential studies of figures in the history of philosophy, including spinoza, leibniz, hume, kant, nietzsche, and bergson, as well as a number of works on. Deleuze and theology christopher ben simpson download. This meaning is more common within christian and other monotheist theology, in which the one god is considered to transcend his creation. It seeks to extract the inner consistency of deleuze s thought by returning to its source or to what, following. The term immanence has several interlinked meanings in deleuze s work. Immanence deleuze and philosophy edinburgh university press. Starting from the famous statement by deleuze and guattari in what is philosophy. Plato and the simulacrum gilles deleuze translated by rosalind krauss what is meant by the overthrow of platonism. It is to the degree that he goes beyond the aporias of the subject and the object that johann fichte, in his last philosophy, presents the transcendental field as a life, no longer dependent on a being or submitted to an act.
The thesis critically analyses the dominant foundationalist tendency of modern philosophy, with special reference to the sophisticated antifoundationalist critiques of foundationalism formulated by g. Deleuze characterized his own work as a philosophy of immanence, arguing that kant himself had failed to realize fully the ambitions of his. Is there a single meaning of the term immanence in the philosophy of gilles. Colebrook begins by historicising the progression of deleuze s ideas as a movement away from structuralism, and the negative dialectic, in the post1968 context towards theorising relations between art, science and philosophy as an affirmative strategy of positive difference. Kants critical philosophy the doctrine of the faculties gilles deleuze translated by hugh tomlinson and barbara habberjam the athlone press london 1984. Although the notion of immanence is frequently held to. Pdf the concepts of transcendence and immanence in. Deleuze rejects the idea that life and creation are opposed to death and noncreation. Another meaning of immanence is the quality of being contained within, or remaining within the boundaries of a person, of the world, or of the mind. August, 2014 daniel colucciello barber, deleuze and the naming of god. Can the entire history of philosophy be presented from the viewpoint of the instituting of a plane of immanence. This chapter situates deleuze s approach to the disciplinarity of philosophy within a transdisciplinary problematic centering on the notion of practice, as well as on questions of politics. The importance of the concept of immanence is manifest through.
The last, seemingly minor question of a life is thus inseparable from deleuze s striking image of philosophy not as a wisdom we already possess, but as a pure immanence of what is yet to come. One of the terminological constants in deleuze s philosophical work is the word immanence. While using philosophy as a resource for theology is nothing new, gilles deleuze 19251995 presents a kind of limitcase for such a theological appropriation of philosophy. The phrase seems to mean abolishing the world of essences and the world of appearances. Deleuze and the meanings of immanence paper for after 68, jan van eyck academy, maastricht, 16 june, 2009. Multiplicities, thresholds, potentialities, trinity college dublin, 810 april 2016. Deleuze s lectures were already mustsee events, and the transcript of the seminar shows why this must have beenthe case. That this ancient and welltravelled notion of immanence is held to have been given new life and new meaning by gilles deleu. However, deleuze s arguments against those critiques by kant, hegel, husserl and heidegger consolidate the philosophy of immanence that can be called transcendental empiricism. It is not immanence to life, but the immanent that is in nothingis itselfa life.
Of deleuze, we could say what he himself said of spinoza, to whom he devoted two books and many lecture courses. Deleuze and guattari differentiate between philosophy, science, and the arts, seeing as means of confronting chaos, and challenge the common view that philosophy is an extension of logic. I want to read deleuze s critique of kant and conceive the importance of kant in deleuzian philosophy of immanence. Immanence deleuze and philosophy edinburgh university. Deleuze s aim in this chapter is to show the failure of this project. Christian kerslake argues that such an interpretation. Kant s critical philosophy the doctrine of the faculties. Reader immanence immanence in deleuze can the entire. Deleuzes text, which will be our sole subject of study for the rest of this chapter, bears the title immanence. A life is the immanence ofimmanence, absolute immanence. How does his philosophy of film combine and further his approaches to time, movement, and perception, and how does it produce an escape from subjectivity and a plunge into the immanence of images. It may be that believing in this world, this life, becomes our most difficult task, or the task of a mode. Being, deleuze succeeds in locating every postulate of transcendence on. Deleuze on kant transcendental stuff vs radical immanence.
It is a tale spun by an extremely talented philosopher who, already in his early thirties, in. One of the terminological constants in the philosophical work of gilles deleuze is the word immanence, and it has therefore become a foothold for those wishing to understand exactly what deleuzian philosophy is. On that basis, it is widely believed that deleuze s project is premised on a return to a materialist metaphysics. Most of all, per haps, it is a book of philosophy as a practice of. The non philosophy of gilles deleuze takes up deleuze s most powerful argument on the task of contemporary philosophy in the west. In the process, he will make the claim that underlying representation is a structure that is different in kind from it. Deleuze on kant transcendental stuff vs radical immanence where do we start. Perhaps the full exploitation of that image, from one of the most original trajectories in contemporary philosophy, is also yet to come. This time the topic was narrower, the concepts of transcendence and immanence in philosophy and theology dialogo 2016 tipt, and it held inperson at ovidius university. Identifies immanence as the original impetus and the driving force behind deleuze s philosophy. By returning deleuze s thought to its sourceor, following deleuze s own vocabulary, to what he calls the event of that thoughtbeistegui extracts its inner consistency. Deleuze s approach to philosophy s disciplinarity and. It seeks to extract the inner consistency of deleuze s thought by returning to itssource or to what, following deleuze s own vocabulary, it calls theevent of that thought.
999 279 1299 336 762 1025 937 713 17 1415 458 205 153 1266 627 6 457 914 277 474 340 1465 228 575 684 72 912 176 1435 126 96 208 989 174 871 1380